Jan 31 2010
Torn Curtain review
work.”
Reviewed by Dennis Schwartz
Alfred Hitchcock’s 50th film is a Cold War romantic-spy story inspired
by a real incident; it aims at making the spy story more realistic (showing
how difficult it’s to kill someone in its piece de resistance farm scene
kitchen murder) rather than cartoonish like the popular but unbelievable
James Bond thrillers. Torn Curtain turns out to be more about domestic
trust than a tough Cold War yarn, which displeased many critics and the
public as they both evidently expected more of a thriller with Bond-like
touches of light comedy. It’s flawed by its plodding pace, its banal politics,
Paul Newman’s wooden performance, its overlong 128-minute length, and too
many rambling scenes that break down due to the director’s shoddy handling
of details (something that’s an anathema to the usual Hitchcock concern
about the finer points). Though only relegated to be a minor film in the
master’s oeuvre, it still has his magical touches in a few splendidly chilling
scenes and can be viewed as a vastly underrated work that holds up when
viewed at the end of the Cold War for its sharply-observed humanitarian
point of view (real people were murdered by spies, even those who were
on the side of the so-called good guys were murderers, and did it not in
a Hollywood septic way).
Paul Newman plays Michael Armstrong, a gifted American physicist
engaged to his gritty science assistant Dr. Sarah Louise Sherman (Julie
Andrews). While attending a science convention in Copenhagen, Denmark,
Armstrong defects to East Berlin, claiming he’s disappointed Washington
canceled his pet project on nuclear defense and hopes to work with the
commies to develop a defense system to make nuclear war passé. Sarah,
not knowing he’s playing a double-agent game to pump Eastern bloc scientist
Professor Gustav Lindt for info on the missing piece of the puzzle to the
nuclear problem he’s working on, surprises him by showing up in East Berlin
and making it more difficult for him to operate.
Warning: spoiler to follow.
When Armstrong secretly treks to a country farmhouse to make contact
with those inside East Germany who are willing to help him, he’s detected
by his annoyingly clever heavy-handed assigned security guard watchdog
Gromek (Wolfgang Kieling) and has no choice, with the help of the farm
woman (Carolyn Conwell), to kill him in a bitter struggle involving a pummeling,
strangulation, knifing and suffocation in a gas oven (mindful of the way
the Nazis did things) that’s well filmed and as unpleasantly memorable
as any murder scene in a Hitchcock film (that includes the shower scene
in Psycho, though one can argue he improved the murder scene even more
in his 1972 Frenzy). Gromek’s disappearance means Armstrong must act fast
to get his mission accomplished. It results in an unconvincing scene where
he picks Lindt’s brain while tossing around mathematical equations on a
blackboard and getting the commie scientist all worked up that he’s not
up to snuff so that in his vainness he lets out the formula to show he’s
a genius. Armstrong then lets a relieved Sarah in on his secret mission
and the two try to escape the country with the help of an organization
called Pi operating inside East Germany, who take them to their next contact
via a fake bus. When detected watching a ballerina performance (Tamara
Toumanova, real-life ballerina) Armstrong shouts out fire in the crowded
theater causing hysteria even though there was no smoke or fire detected,
and the two lovers escape by boat to return to the American way of life.

